This Week's High/Low: Poor Things / Lisa FrankensteinWe're doing a monster mash this week, y’all! Since both films are about reanimated corpses, I figured I should Frankenstein these reviews together.
Lisa Frankenstein tells the story of high school freakazoid Lisa (Kathryn Newton) who is trying to fit in at her new school after her mom gets axe-murdered and she moves in with her dad's new wife and stepsister. Naturally, the only "person" she grows close to is the grave of a young man in an abandoned cemetery—who, after one fateful storm, comes back to life. Classic stuff!
Poor Things is the story of Bella Baxter (Emma Stone), a woman who took her own life (her choice!) and is brought back to life (not her choice!) with the brain of the child she was carrying via a mad scientist whom she calls "God." From there she goes on a wild journey of self-discovery, pleasure, and humanity. Even more classic stuff!!!!
After watching
Lisa Frankenstein (streaming on Peacock) this weekend, I was mulling over how it compared to
Poor Things, the much more "Criterion Collection" take on Mary Shelley's masterpiece. The former, an ode to '80s horny teen comedies with a darker
Heathers twist, written by Diablo Cody and directed by Zelda Williams. The latter, an Oscar-winning Victorian fantasy by Yorgos Lanthimos. One clocks in at a breezy 90 minutes, the other nearly 2.5 hours.
Sure, the vibes and overall, shall we say, aspirations of these films are quite different.
Lisa Frankenstein is not trying to be serious, and thank Hot Topic for that. But at the black heart of them both is a gothic tale of an undead being seeking love and understanding, begging the same question that
Barbie made famous, "what was I made for?"
Perhaps my favorite common thread of these two macabre films is the importance they both put on physical acting. My boy Cole Sprouse, who plays Creature in
Lisa Frankenstein, has nary a line until the very last scene (we love a man who doesn't speak!). His whole story is told in grunts, through a body that's trying to un-remember rigor mortis.To delightful comedic results, natch. Meanwhile Emma Stone develops from infancy in an adult body, unlocking the magic we all had as babies discovering our toes for the first time. This is all happening while the men surrounding her place their wills and desires on top of her. No easy
feet.
Oddly enough, one of the more striking differences (other than, basically everything except for the
Frankenstein source material tbh) is the level of agency said undead beings possess from the moment of reanimation. Sure, we watch Bella come into herself, but her existence is initially void of any agency whatsoever (I know, I know, that's the point!). Over in
Lisa Frankenstein land, Creature comes to life because of a storm that sent a lightning strike through his grave. Mother nature was the only one who had any hand in that.
And I don't think it's a coincidence that one film is written and directed by a man while the other is written and directed by two women. I'M JUST SAYING!!!! I know there was a lot of controversy around
Poor Things and the whole question if Bella was mentally a child while experiencing sex for the first time. I don't exactly have the answer for that, I think we can comfortably assume she's reached mental puberty by the time that moment arrives. But my bigger gripe with the film is that the male gaze is all over it. Alllllllll over it.
On a technical level, yes, of course
Poor Things is a "better" movie. Emma Stone is really put through the acting paces via Lanthimos, and the trippy production design adds a dimension of surreality that is singular to its director.
Lisa Frankenstein is a silly movie with some style problems (how hard are we going for parody or reality?) and more than a few plot holes, but it is hella fun. It's a movie that's winking at you 95% of the time and being utterly sincere the other 5%, and those moments really land. Sitting in bed with Creature, talking about the grief of losing her mother, Lisa laments, "They say time heals all wounds. But that's a lie, time is the wound." Diablo Cody's pen strikes again!
So what's the big takeaway here? I'm glad both of these films exist at the very same time. There's room in Hollywood, and our own cinematic tastes, for auteurs and their muses along with "let's have some fun" indie genre films. I would be so bored otherwise.